The Henryetta Sleepover Murders, Part 2
Sep 14
1 min read
In May 2023, the small community of Henryetta, Oklahoma was shaken by the discovery of seven bodies on a rural property — a murder‑suicide carried out by Jesse McFadden, 39, a registered sex offender. McFadden killed his wife, Holly Guess, 35, her three children — Rylee Elizabeth Allen, 17, Michael James Mayo, 15, and Tiffany Dore Guess, 13 — along with two teenage girls who were staying over for a sleepover, Ivy Webster, 14, and Brittany Brewer, 15, before taking his own life. The case exposed deep failures in the supervision of violent offenders, raised urgent questions about investigative gaps, and left families demanding accountability for a system that failed to protect six young people and a mother.
CASE IMAGES
Victims of Jesse McFadden Ivy Ivy Brittany Brittany Holly Tiffany Tiffany Rylee Tiffany, Nathan, and Rylee Nathan Nathan Holly, Nathan, Rylee, and Tiffany Family photos in the McFadden home Holly & Jesse McFadden's home Shackles installed in the bedroom Chains installed in the bedroom Shackle on the kitchen island Chains installed in the house Nathan Brewer, Brittany's father Ivy's parents Ashleigh Webster's TikTok EMA Missing person flyer EMA Missing Persons flyer Parents finding evidence in plain sight Technology not seized Parents finding evidence in plain sight Technology not seized from Jesse's home Evidence in plain sight Technology not seized Evidence Evidence Memorial trees before they were planted Memorial markers Memorial tree planting Memorial tree planting Rylee's memorial tree Michael's memorial tree Ivy's memorial tree Ivy's memorial marker Tiffany's tree memorial Tiffany's memorial tree Brittany's tree memorial Brittany's Memorial Tree Brittany's Memorial Memorial trees in front of the school in 2026 Memoriam from Henryetta Schools Car wash fundraiser for Uknighted Knights Law advocacy The Webster family - Knights Law Advocacy Arial view of the home Holly and Jesse Crystal Strong Jesse Jesse's booking information Jesse's booking photo in 2004 Jesse Jesse The McFadden home caught on fire Cory McFadden, Jesse's brother
Comments